Is there an innate Sa?
Decoding Sound in Himalayan schools: a game to find the note each of us calls home.
Decoding Sound travelled. Over a series of workshops in schools across the foothills of the Himalayas, we took one question from classroom to classroom, and ended the journey at Hill Hacks 2016, the hackers’ gathering at Ghoomakad, in the village of Rakkar near Dharamsala in Himachal Pradesh.1 The question was about fundamental resonance: does each of us carry a home note?
The intention
The game is a way to learn what Sa is by feeling it rather than being told. In Indian music Sa is not a fixed frequency. There is no equivalent of Western concert pitch, where A is set at 440 Hz: each performer chooses a Sa that suits their own voice, and all the instruments follow it.2,3 That choice is not made once for life. It moves with the time of day, with the mood of the music and with the state of the performer’s body on that day.
So we ask the children, and you, to play more than once: in the morning, in the afternoon and in the evening. Each time, find the note you can hold comfortably for about forty seconds, and save it below. The note that sits easily in your voice at seven in the morning is often not the one that sits easily at seven in the evening. Voice research sees this too, though it differs from person to person: in one study of adult speakers, male voices rose in speaking pitch from morning to afternoon while female voices changed less consistently, and in another, with young female speakers, the effects were too small to measure reliably.4,5 The game makes the change something you notice in your own body, not a number in a paper.
Why rāgs keep time
This leads into an old idea in Hindustani music, that each rāg has its hour: Bhairav at dawn, Yaman as evening falls, Darbari Kanada late at night. Not everything is meant to be sung at any time of day. In the early twentieth century V. N. Bhatkhande tried to explain this rule through the notes themselves. He linked the rāgs of the twilight hours, the sandhi prakāsh rāgs, to a flattened Re, and suggested there was a psycho-physiological basis, though he never showed what it was.6,7 The historian Mukund Lath traces the rule back to medieval texts and reads it as partly learned: a convention that listeners absorb, and that has loosened in practice, for example on All India Radio.8 The game offers a way in through the body. If your own comfortable Sa, and the range around it, shifts through the day, it is easier to understand why musicians came to feel that a rāg belongs to its hour.
The conjecture
In Indian music every performance rests on Sa, the tonic, held by the tanpura or shruti box. Our working conjecture was that each of us has an innate Sa, shaped by the body: the size of the larynx, the length of the throat, the chest and rib cage that we feel humming when we sing low. We all have one Sa; the game below is a way to look for it.
What the science supports
Every body gives a range, and a comfortable place in it. The pitch of the voice, its fundamental frequency, is set mainly by the length, mass and tension of the vocal folds. Ingo Titze showed that the difference between male and female voices is explained largely by vocal-fold length, which differs by a factor of about 1.6.9,10 Children’s voices fall as their folds grow: around age four to six, typical speaking pitch is about 245–257 Hz for male and female children alike, and young male voices begin to drop around eight.11 An adult voice can span more than three octaves,12 and within that span most people find a zone that feels easy.
Sa is chosen to fit the voice. This is the strongest support for the idea. Indian art music has no fixed concert pitch; as music researchers put it, the tonic is “a base pitch chosen by the performer” so that they can fully explore their vocal range, and all accompanying instruments are tuned to it.2,3 The theory behind it, from the śrutis of Bharata’s Nāṭyaśāstra onwards, describes relationships between notes rather than fixed frequencies.13,14 In practice, then, every singer really does have their own Sa.
The body favours some notes. Below the larynx, the windpipe and lungs have resonances of their own, fixed by anatomy, and laboratory work shows they can help or hinder the vocal folds at particular pitches.15 That is the most defensible scientific version of “your body prefers certain notes”.
What it does not support, yet
A single fixed note set by the rib cage. Within adults of the same sex, body size barely predicts pitch: in a meta-analysis of 39 samples, voice pitch explained less than 2% of the variation in height among males and 0.5% among females.16,17 Body size tracks the length of the vocal tract much better, which shapes the colour of a voice, not the note it sings.18
Chest voice is felt, not tuned. The buzz singers feel in the sternum mostly reflects pressure in the airway and the strength of the voice’s fundamental; it is feedback to the singer rather than a resonator that picks the pitch.19
A comfortable pitch moves. Voice clinicians have long searched for an “optimal pitch”, but the classic rule, a quarter of the way up the range, was not confirmed, and whether a “wrong” pitch causes voice problems is still debated.20,21 The note you hum easily changes with the time of day, mood and practice, which is the point of the game.
So we treat the innate Sa as a conjecture, and the game as a way to find the Sa that feels like home today. We stay away from claims about a personal “body frequency” or 432 Hz, which have no controlled evidence behind them.22
The game
Hum or sing one steady, comfortable note. The microphone finds its pitch, folds it into one of the twelve notes of the octave, and an animal appears for that note, from the Rat on C to the Pig on B. Hold the note and the animal walks; let it waver and it dissolves back into noise. For many children it was the first time they had seen their own voice, and a microphone is an honest mirror: we hear ourselves partly through our bones, which is why a recording of our own voice sounds strange.23
Seeing a pitch helps children learn to hold one. Graham Welch describes singing in tune as a skill learned through feedback, and his SINGAD system showed that real-time visual feedback improved children’s pitch accuracy; focused singing instruction speeds this up.24,25,26 The animals are drawn as barrier-grid, or picket-fence, animation: each animal’s frames are interlaced and a striped grid moves across them, the same trick as the early twentieth-century ombro-cinéma toy and Rufus Seder’s Scanimation books.27
Noise
- C Rat
- C# Ox
- D Tiger
- D# Rabbit
- E Dragon
- F Snake
- F# Horse
- G Goat
- G# Monkey
- A Rooster
- A# Dog
- B Pig
Your Sa through the day
Saved only in this browser, on this device.
Allow the microphone when the browser asks. No microphone? Hold a key A W S E D F T G Y H U J to hear and see each note.
References
- hillhacks: our history (hillhacks 2, 2016, at Ghoomakad, Rakkar, near Dharamsala). Link
- Salamon, J., Gulati, S. & Serra, X. (2012). A multipitch approach to tonic identification in Indian classical music. Proceedings of ISMIR 2012. Link
- Gulati, S., Bellur, A., Salamon, J., Ranjani, H. G., Ishwar, V., Murthy, H. A. & Serra, X. (2014). Automatic tonic identification in Indian art music: approaches and evaluation. Journal of New Music Research 43(1), 53–71. Link
- Garrett, K. L. & Healey, E. C. (1987). An acoustic analysis of fluctuations in the voices of normal adult speakers across three times of day. JASA 82(1), 58–62. Link
- van Mersbergen, M. R., Verdolini, K. & Titze, I. R. (1999). Time-of-day effects on voice range profile performance in young, vocally untrained adult females. Journal of Voice 13(4), 518–528. Link
- Bhatkhande, V. N. (1934). A Short Historical Survey of the Music of Upper India. Text of a speech given at the All-India Music Conference, Baroda, 1916.
- Jairazbhoy, N. A. (1971). The Rāgs of North Indian Music: Their Structure and Evolution. Faber and Faber.
- Lath, M. An enquiry into the rāga–time association. Jijñāsā: Journal of the History of Ideas and Culture, University of Rajasthan, Jaipur. Link
- Titze, I. R. (1989). Physiologic and acoustic differences between male and female voices. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 85(4), 1699–1707.
- Titze, I. R. (1994). Principles of Voice Production. Prentice Hall (reprinted by the National Center for Voice and Speech, 2000).
- Fujiki, R. B., Venkatraman, A. & Heller Murray, E. (2025). The pediatric vocal mechanism: structure and function. Journal of Voice. Link
- Hollien, H., Dew, D. & Philips, P. (1971). Phonational frequency ranges of adults. Journal of Speech and Hearing Research 14(4), 755–760. Link
- Ghosh, M. (trans.) (1951/1961). The Nāṭyaśāstra ascribed to Bharata-Muni, ch. 28 (śrutis and grāmas). The Asiatic Society, Calcutta.
- Rowell, L. (1992). Music and Musical Thought in Early India. University of Chicago Press. Link
- Austin, S. F. & Titze, I. R. (1997). The effect of subglottal resonance upon vocal fold vibration. Journal of Voice 11(4), 391–402. Link
- Pisanski, K. et al. (2014). Vocal indicators of body size in men and women: a meta-analysis. Animal Behaviour 95, 89–99. Link
- Rendall, D., Kollias, S., Ney, C. & Lloyd, P. (2005). Pitch (F0) and formant profiles of human vowels and vowel-like baboon grunts: the role of vocalizer body size and voice-acoustic allometry. JASA 117(2), 944–955.
- Fitch, W. T. & Giedd, J. (1999). Morphology and development of the human vocal tract: a study using magnetic resonance imaging. JASA 106(3), 1511–1522. Link
- Sundberg, J. (1983). Chest wall vibrations in singers. Journal of Speech and Hearing Research 26(3), 329–340. Link
- A comparison of habitual and derived optimal voice fundamental frequency values in normal young adult speakers (1990). Journal of Speech and Hearing Disorders 55(3), 476ff; Fairbanks, G. (1960). Voice and Articulation Drillbook. Harper & Row. Link
- Roy, N. & Hendarto, H. (2005). Revisiting the pitch controversy: changes in speaking fundamental frequency after management of functional dysphonia. Journal of Voice 19(4), 582–591. Link
- Calamassi, D. & Pomponi, G. P. (2019). Music tuned to 440 Hz versus 432 Hz and the health effects: a double-blind cross-over pilot study. Explore 15(4), 283–290 (corrigendum 2020). Link
- Reinfeldt, S., Östli, P., Håkansson, B. & Stenfelt, S. (2010). Hearing one’s own voice during phoneme vocalization: transmission by air and bone conduction. JASA 128(2), 751–762. Link
- Welch, G. F. (1985). A schema theory of how children learn to sing in tune. Psychology of Music 13(1), 3–18. Link
- Welch, G. F., Howard, D. M. & Rush, C. (1989). Real-time visual feedback in the development of vocal pitch accuracy in singing. Psychology of Music 17(2), 146–157. Link
- Demorest, S. M., Nichols, B. & Pfordresher, P. Q. (2018). The effect of focused instruction on young children’s singing accuracy. Psychology of Music. Link
- Seder, R. B. (2006). Moveable animated display device (Scanimation). US Patent 7,151,541; on the history of barrier-grid animation, from the ombro-cinéma toy to kinegrams. Link
Have a space, a sound or an idea?
We design custom immersive experiences and tools for artists and businesses, and we’re always looking for spaces to listen to.
contact@sound.codes